How do I know if I need a divorce?

“Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.”
— Tolstoy

You’ve probably landed on this website because you are concerned about unhappiness in your family. Maybe a silent cancer crept through your home and ate away at your marriage while you were busy raising children or launching your career. Or maybe your homelife has become a stage for loud and angry scenes. The fighting never seems to end, and nothing is resolved. You’ve unloaded your grievances but done it in such a way as to cause further damage to your relationship. Somebody starts thinking that life together has become intolerable. Maybe threats have even been made like “that’s it, I’m leaving!”, or “I’m done!”

Marriages end for countless reasons. Some couples never learn how to communicate with each other, so they fail to understand the other person’s needs and by extension will fail to meet them. Some couples fall into destructive patterns of arguing, saying mean words which cannot be taken back, or even attacking each other physically. Awful things can happen, like illnesses, deaths, addictions, and financial or work problems, which couples find they cannot recover from. In less dramatic but still painful marriages a gulf may develop between the partners that is so deep and wide as to become impassable. Perhaps they still even love each other, but the connection and the passion are faded memories. New love interests find purchase in troubled marriages, even in marriages where both partners thought that they were happy. Affairs don’t have to be physical in order to break up marriages; even the triangulation caused by “emotional affairs” can be powerful enough to disrupt the marital union.

We marry for love. We marry with joy. And we expect our marriage to last a lifetime, even though we may be well aware of each other’s foibles and conflicts. If you choose your spouse wisely, worked hard to nurture your relationship, and were spared cataclysmic losses and stressors, your love might be strong enough to counterbalance the problems that arise when people live together over time. But if you were that fortunate, you probably wouldn’t be reading this book.

For most couples, the decision to marry was not an impulsive one: there were many loving conversations about what it would be like to commit to each other, and there are many opportunities in dating life to try on aspects of married life. Perhaps you lived together before marriage, or maybe you vacationed together. You made decisions together, and watched each other handle tough situations, all of which folded together into shared experience. And probably you talked together about marriage, or growing old together, or having a family, long before a proposal was made or a ring was proffered. In all likelihood you thought about marriage for months or even years before you decided to go forward with it.

Note my emphasis on the word “together”. Love and marriage are built by couples working, communicating and planning with each other. Few fiancés are surprised these days by marriage proposals, even if the precise time and place might be unexpected. Most couples in love can feel when marriage is in the air, and have inched towards conversations about life together, even if they feel awkward and self-conscious when the topic arises.

Shouldn’t there be some similar process for thinking about divorce?

You already know that divorce is not an action to be taken lightly. This is one of the most important decisions of your life, which is why it demands careful consideration and discussion. In the heat of the moment, when you are in a rage and your brain is flooded with stress hormones like cortisol and adrenaline, you are unlikely to be able to accurately assess your situation or determine your best course of action. Considering the many ramifications of your decision, from children to finances, and extended family to social connections, you want to make sure that your thoughts and emotions all line up together before taking action.